Abstract:Purpose: Through meta analysis of fusion and non-fusion ,we evaluated the efficacy and safety of them in treat ment of lumbar stenosis with spondylolisthesis; and to provide evidence for clinical decisions of mild lumbar stenosis with spondylolisthesis. Methods: We searched database of computer and annually searched related journals in order to collect those researches for comparation of fusion and non-fusion that met the inclusion criteria,so that we coule evaluate the comparation systematicly. Results:We brought into a total of 8 literatures,including 595 cases. A total of 595 patients were identified, with 307 in the fusion procedure group and 288 in the non -fusion procedure group. Major findings from the meta-analysis showed that: 1) Operation time was significantly longer in the fusion than non-fusion procedure group [MD=4.15, 95%CI (-0.07, 8.36), P=0.05]; 2) Average amount of bleeding during the surgeries was significantly more in the fusion than non-fusion procedure group [MD=3.98, 95%CI (2.12, 5.84), P<0.00001]; 3) the fusion is more effective than non-fusion procedure group [OR=1.7-, 95%CI (1.02, 2.84), P=0.04]; 4) Post-operative VAS scoring improved more significantly in the fusion than non-fusion procedure group [MD=-2.35, 95%CI (-3.68, -1.03), P=0.00005]; 5) No statistically significant difference was observed in intervertebral space between the two groups; 6) Degree of spondylolisthesis was less severe in the fusion than non-fusion group [MD=-1.72, 95%CI (-2.76, -0.68), P=0.001]; 7) Post-operative complications were higher in the fusion than non-fusion group [OR=2.68, 95%CI (1.18, 6.05), P=0.02]. Conclusions: Both of fusion and non-fusion procedures prove to be effective in treating lumbar stenosis with spondylolisthesis. Fusion procedures showed more superiority in treatment efficacy, post operative VAS scoring, and degree of spondylolisthesis; while non-fusion procedures were more superior in surgical time, amount of heamorrhage during surgery, and post operative complications. All told, fusion procedure showed significantly better outcomes in improving lumbar syndromes and post-operative spondylolisthesis. However, findings need to be interpreted cautiously due to small sample size and more randomized controlled trials with larger sample sizes are warranted to obtain high quality of evidence.